I had a fourth July party and I ordered a bunch of pies they came on time and they were delicious. I also ordered a entree of penne alla vodka and the sauce was amazing

  I came to Hicksville in Hope of running into Teresa Caputo but found the best Italian food I've ever eaten. This quaint little pizzeria has lots of charm & the staff there was awesome... Thanks to Kelli, we had amazing service & they even made us a stuffed pizza pie the 2nd time 😊but their lunch specials are unbeatable ( even left-overs later were delish)& fried zucchini was to die for...of course we went back the next day b4 leaving town. We just couldn't help ourselves. Very reasonably priced & large portions. Hope I get to come back again someday.

  I was shopping at John's Farm's and was hungry so I decided to stop by and check the menu and landed on chicken Alfredo pasta. It was so good it melts in your mouth. I will have to try other things on their menu. And while I was eating love how there always a fresh pie coming out the oven. Will come here more often because it is nice to see a new local spot to eat.

  Best pizza place around. They have the most friendly workers ever! The pizzas great, everything is perfect about it! I recommend that everyone should go here for lunch/dinner. Everything is fresh, clean, and the best!

  You cannot get better value for pizza. It is rather crazy how these guys are able to operate by selling a pizza pie under 18 dollars. Grandma slice is good as well, as white. Make sure you eat the pizza when it is hot or ask them to warm it up, definitely makes a difference in taste.

  I went here for a quick lunch and I ordered the penne alla vodka with grilled chicken and it was absolutely delicious! , I’ll surely be coming back for more !

  I've eaten great pizza and great chicken parm at this restaurant. But last night was a huge disappointment. I ordered Chicken Francese with linguini. I get it home, I open it up and there was a lime wedge. Yes a lime wedge instead of a lemon wedge. The chicken and linguini were so bland except for a hint of lime. I should have brought it back, but I didn't. I'll have to get lemons and try to salvage it. Not a bad place, but don't order chicken francese.

  I ate the best pie after a long time.. the dough is so fresh and the toppings are really good un this. The staff is very friendly. Definitely Will be back

  Great New York Italian Pizza. Grew up on this stuff, and it's amazing. The owner is a great guy, too!

  One of the best pizzeria on the island love their pizza roles and the the sizzling bbq keep it up #checkoutmystore