-
Great food always. Atmosphere is always clean and employees are always ready to help. They never slack on delivers as well always on time and very hot and fresh. I... read more usually always go for the classic slices and there specialty slices are very good as well. Owner is awesome as well.
Bryan Contreras
February 14, 2020 -
Started coming here a couple of months ago and their food is first rate. They get everything right. As a lifelong New Yorker, who is really picky about my pizza,... read more this place is the best I have had in thirty years. The Grandma's Pie is the best I have ever had. Don't change anything! It's all about the sauce. Try their food, you won't regret it. Prices are great as well!
Nancy Krumm
June 14, 2020You cannot get better value for pizza. It is rather crazy how these guys are able to operate by selling a pizza pie under 18 dollars. Grandma slice is good... read more as well, as white. Make sure you eat the pizza when it is hot or ask them to warm it up, definitely makes a difference in taste.
Jon Li
April 12, 2018 -
I came to Hicksville in Hope of running into Teresa Caputo but found the best Italian food I've ever eaten. This quaint little pizzeria has lots of charm & the... read more staff there was awesome... Thanks to Kelli, we had amazing service & they even made us a stuffed pizza pie the 2nd time 😊but their lunch specials are unbeatable ( even left-overs later were delish)& fried zucchini was to die for...of course we went back the next day b4 leaving town. We just couldn't help ourselves. Very reasonably priced & large portions. Hope I get to come back again someday.
T Wheeler
August 22, 2018 -
Mama Lino's is the only reason I made it through the pandemic. Everything I have ordered from them far exceeded my expectations in quality, freshness, and value on every beat. The only... read more issues I ever had were with the food delivery app, and never the restaurant. Trust me they deliver better than any of the apps, just call them. Their salads are fresh and well made with satisfying portions and good variety. Their pizzas are amazing, this goes without saying, and again that same perfectly chewy/crunchy dough used in their garlic knots and zeppolis. I really can't get over the texture of this dough, no joke I can just order a soup and a double garlic knot and that's a good dinner for a man with far too much appetite. Their menu is no joke huge! They literally need separate sections for Pastas and Baked Pastas otherwise it would be too much to scroll through. I have never had a late order, and out of maybe 25 there was only 1 mixup between garlic knots and stuffed garlic knots and they had already sent out a guy with the correction (despite it only being a little tray of 4 garlic knots) before we even realized they were missing. I love this place, their food is amazing and their people are even moreso. Mama Lino's, if you live near them there is literally no reason to order a slice from anywhere else. There may be better slices out there, this is NY ffs, but none of them have hit my tastebuds yet.
Shane Pullham
August 24, 2023 -
Daisy
March 13, 2025Mama Lino's is the only reason I made it through the pandemic. Everything I have ordered from them far exceeded my expectations in quality, freshness, and value on every beat.... read more The only issues I ever had were with the food delivery app, and never the restaurant. Trust me they deliver better than any of the apps, just call them. Their salads are fresh and well made with satisfying portions and good variety. Their pizzas are amazing, this goes without saying, and again that same perfectly chewy/crunchy dough used in their garlic knots and zeppolis. I really can't get over the texture of this dough, no joke I can just order a soup and a double garlic knot and that's a good dinner for a man with far too much appetite. Their menu is no joke huge! They literally need separate sections for Pastas and Baked Pastas otherwise it would be too much to scroll through. I have never had a late order, and out of maybe 25 there was only 1 mixup between garlic knots and stuffed garlic knots and they had already sent out a guy with the correction (despite it only being a little tray of 4 garlic knots) before we even realized they were missing. I love this place, their food is amazing and their people are even moreso. Mama Lino's, if you live near them there is literally no reason to order a slice from anywhere else. There may be better slices out there, this is NY ffs, but none of them have hit my tastebuds yet. Dietary restrictions: It's hard to go keto on some delivery food options, Mama Lino's has you covered with plenty of salad selections with protein of your choice. Or none if you prefer.
Shane Pullham
September 9, 2023 -
jamie spotify
November 9, 2023 -
My whole family loves this pizza. Nice thin crusted pizza! It's nice and light! And I liked the baked ziti with ricotta cheese too.
ROXY 6HT
January 21, 2025This place has been my go-to pizza spot for years. I got a cheese pie and meatball pasta to go for the family, and we were all utterly disappointed. Pizza... read more was way too salty and the crust, which is my fav part was not crispy. The pasta noodles were overcooked and tasted worse than a store bought pasta. Not sure what changed, but sad to say I will not be returning here.
Anna Yeo
January 26, 2024 -
This is the best pizza! The crust is thin and perfectly cooked and the cheese and sauce are amazing. My favorite pizza is the Chicken-Onion-Tomato-Ranch. Very clean place, friendly staff,... read more and right next to John’s Market. Love it!!!
Adem Birson
June 29, 2022We ordered baked ravioli, linguine Alfredo and a couple deserts. They told me it would arrive in 30 minutes, which it did. The guy in the phone was... read more friendly and helpful. The food was hot and delicious. The meals came with awesome garlic knots as well. The place isn't too expensive either.
David Donner
May 6, 2023Mamalino’s never disappoints! The pepperoni pinwheel is one of my favorites, especially for how good it is for the price. The buffalo chicken pizza and buffalo chicken roll are both... read more to die for! Everything is delicious, and you definitely get your money’s worth. This is my go to spot when I’m craving a late snack cause it’s open till 2. My only complaint is that it’s not open that late every night. Highly recommend!
shaun simon
October 24, 2026 -
from the moment I entered the place they welcomed me with a big smile, the lasagna was very delicious and I am thinking of visiting them again, I wish them... read more to continue prospering
Maye Fra
August 27, 2019Absolutely I’m love with this place ! My sons baseball team and parents were all in the dining room we got to use it for free!!! They were so nice,... read more we ordered the chicken Parmesan let me tell you the best chicken Parm I have ever had the kids all prefers pizza and now we order them pizza every time after a game. My friend had the seafood supreme it was so delicious and it was such a good price it tasted like I was eating at a high end restaurant.I really recommended make sure you don’t pass out
Ashley Koalski
November 28, 2019 -
Reasonable prices & large portions. I was thrilled to see my salad was chopped the way I like it. Staff is friendly. I used to go to another place nearby... read more (whose name I won’t mention) & they were overpriced, had small portions of food & it was always served with a side of attitude. Not this place. Mama Lino’s is my new go to place for Italian.
Jill Romanowski
April 9, 2023WOW! My husband and I wanted pizza at 10pm and everything in the area was closed. This popped up on Google and we figured we'd try it out and we... read more LOVED it! The regular and Sicilian slices were fantastic and he loved his chicken parm slices as well. The penne ala vodka was also delicious, and we were full and happy after eating. We work late nights so we were ecstatic to see how late this place is opened. The food was better than we expected and we will DEFINITELY be back!
Dana Bryant
July 18, 2025Best pizza in town definitely recommend this place for everyone who loves real authentic Italian food. The pizza with some many toppings and the pasta is so hot and fresh... read more been coming to this place for years this place is always ready to serve you a hot slice come on down you won’t regret it.
Alfredo Alvarez
October 26, 2019Ended up here after a concert at Jones Beach. And couldn't believe it wasn't busier bc it's only 20 ish mins away! And it was fantastic! Just a classic nice... read more thin crust NY pizza. We were very happy w this choice and now we know where to go after shows we end up back down here again!
Leelee
October 6, 2025











