4.4
Based on 334 reviews
  • Mama Lino’s is the best around. Their grandma and Buffalo slices are incredibly delicious! Make sure you check them out you won’t be disappointed 🔥

    media thumbnail 0
    Eats With Brandon Avatar Eats With Brandon
    September 21, 2024

    These guys never fail to satisfy customers! Always friendly, very fast orders and delicious pizza!

    Adam Sherif Avatar Adam Sherif
    April 10, 2021

    Love this place, been coming here for years and there food never disappoints👍🏼

    Jay Marr Avatar Jay Marr
    May 22, 2021

    Great food always. Atmosphere is always clean and employees are always ready to help. They never slack on delivers as well always on time and very hot and fresh. I... read more

    Bryan Contreras Avatar Bryan Contreras
    February 14, 2020

    Awesome spot for late night pasta and pizza!!! Always delicious and consistent.

    Michael A Avatar Michael A
    May 3, 2025

    Ordered takeout, first time, impressed. Vegan pizza nice seasoning with cauliflower crust. Service was polite and did everything himself. Excellent experience

    John Unorthodox Avatar John Unorthodox
    March 30, 2025
  • In my opinion I feel so welcomed when I go to pick up, I had ordered a family special and it was a bargain!! Got 3 dinners for $31.99!!

    Joanna Henriquez Avatar Joanna Henriquez
    September 23, 2020

    good food good prices

    Mathew Hall Avatar Mathew Hall
    February 19, 2025

    Started coming here a couple of months ago and their food is first rate. They get everything right. As a lifelong New Yorker, who is really picky about my pizza,... read more

    Nancy Krumm Avatar Nancy Krumm
    June 14, 2020

    Today I had a Montana penne it was great. the veggies were fresh chicken was moist and just the right amount of garlic and oil I def would recommend.

    Jason Molofsky Avatar Jason Molofsky
    January 17, 2020

    Chicken ranch pizza top notch

    M TAQI Avatar M TAQI
    September 21, 2024

    You cannot get better value for pizza. It is rather crazy how these guys are able to operate by selling a pizza pie under 18 dollars. Grandma slice is good... read more

    Jon Li Avatar Jon Li
    April 12, 2018
  • This place is amazing, me and my family love to eat here. The people here are very nice, I would 100% recommend. And the food is the best!

    Recinos family Avatar Recinos family
    June 10, 2019

    The food was very good and they’re open late.

    Jenni Cruz Avatar Jenni Cruz
    June 16, 2025

    My wife and i love this place. Great meatballs.

    Anthony Vinciguerra Avatar Anthony Vinciguerra
    February 9, 2023

    I went here for a quick lunch and I ordered the penne alla vodka with grilled chicken and it was absolutely delicious! , I’ll surely be coming back for more... read more

    Jennifer Lynch Avatar Jennifer Lynch
    November 27, 2017

    Best pizza in Plainview

    Bhoges Avatar Bhoges
    August 9, 2023

    I came to Hicksville in Hope of running into Teresa Caputo but found the best Italian food I've ever eaten. This quaint little pizzeria has lots of charm & the... read more

    T Wheeler Avatar T Wheeler
    August 22, 2018
  • Ordered delivery from Mama Lino’s when we were in town staying after a concert. It did NOT disappoint, the chicken parm pizza and the bbq chicken salad were SO GOOD.

    Kelly Black Avatar Kelly Black
    August 13, 2025

    The pizza was delicious and I really recommend to go and enjoy with friends or family and try some of the delicious dishes that they prepare

    Edenilson Francia Avatar Edenilson Francia
    August 27, 2019

    Fantastic food, quick and friendly service, really just a bunch of great people making great food at affordable prices.

    Jacob Rokofsky Avatar Jacob Rokofsky
    February 3, 2024

    This place is amazing i come here multiple days out of the week and it never disappoints. The people here are so kind and serve the best food.

    Hans Avatar Hans
    August 5, 2026

    Mama Lino's is the only reason I made it through the pandemic. Everything I have ordered from them far exceeded my expectations in quality, freshness, and value on every beat. The only... read more

    Shane Pullham Avatar Shane Pullham
    August 24, 2023

    Best pizza I've ever had. The garlic knots are delicious, the sauce is perfect. I order a simple pepperoni pizza garlic knots. The owner was very kind. The girl who... read more

    Alpha Lister Avatar Alpha Lister
    July 26, 2021
  • Dope customer experience from the gentleman working in the front. He had a bit of an accent but the gentleman was really courteous. Did I mention the pizza and... read more

    Mohammad Mashriqi Avatar Mohammad Mashriqi
    July 9, 2023

    Been coming here for years. I have never once had a pie where the bottom or crusts were overdone/burnt. Always perfect and thin 👌🏼

    Timothy L Avatar Timothy L
    December 24, 2021

    Food is very satisfactory. I love their Shrimp Francese! And their very typical NY pizza 🤎.

    Daisy Avatar Daisy
    March 13, 2025

    Mama Lino's is the only reason I made it through the pandemic. Everything I have ordered from them far exceeded my expectations in quality, freshness, and value on every beat.... read more

    Shane Pullham Avatar Shane Pullham
    September 9, 2023

    The cauliflower pizza was the best thing I ever tasted. The best pizza spot in town and the staff was friendly. I love Mama Lino’s for pizza and I am... read more

    Misinga A Avatar Misinga A
    April 7, 2019

    Went in today and got chicken parm entree and overall very good , came with garlic knots and they were nice and fresh.

    Joanna Henriquez Avatar Joanna Henriquez
    January 6, 2019
  • Ordered a pizza and some pasta and the delivery was quick and the food was still hot and delicious. Would recommend 10/10

    Kelly K Avatar Kelly K
    May 18, 2021

    I loved this pizzeria. The quality is amazing, and I really like that the pepperoni pizza doesn’t have too much dough or too much tomato—it’s simply perfect.

    santiago velez Avatar santiago velez
    May 17, 2025

    Amazing Place to dine!!! The pizza knocks every other place in the area out of the park!

    jamie spotify Avatar jamie spotify
    November 9, 2023

    Finally found a crispy Deep Dish pizza that's not a doughy Sicilian and delicious Pepperoni, generously spread with slices 😋

    Lisa Moffa Avatar Lisa Moffa
    September 21, 2025

    One of the best pizzeria on the island love their pizza roles and the the sizzling bbq keep it up #checkoutmystore

    aman labana Avatar aman labana
    November 15, 2017

    Ordered on Uber Eats. My grilled chicken was amazing! And so was my sautéed spinach ! The portions are very generous I’m always a happy customer..

    Nadia74 Avatar Nadia74
    April 24, 2026
  • My whole family loves this pizza. Nice thin crusted pizza! It's nice and light! And I liked the baked ziti with ricotta cheese too.

    ROXY 6HT Avatar ROXY 6HT
    January 21, 2025

    This place has been my go-to pizza spot for years. I got a cheese pie and meatball pasta to go for the family, and we were all utterly disappointed. Pizza... read more

    media thumbnail 0
    Anna Yeo Avatar Anna Yeo
    January 26, 2024

    I had the brand new chicken over rice and the new cheeseburger and both were absolutely DELICIOUS Vegetarian options: Delicious vegetarian slice Kid-friendliness: Very friendly staff

    DAWD FROM 2016 Avatar DAWD FROM 2016
    November 9, 2023

    I always orden pizza, pasta, chicken salad from these place always is hot and delicious . They have friendly staff and clean place .

    Pat garcia Avatar Pat garcia
    March 27, 2022

    I ordered the chicken francese and the chicken contadina and it was so great, probably one of the best dinners I have ever had go check it out

    Isil Karagoz Avatar Isil Karagoz
    October 18, 2018

    Consistently awesome!!!

    K Avatar K
    September 9, 2023
  • This is the best pizza! The crust is thin and perfectly cooked and the cheese and sauce are amazing. My favorite pizza is the Chicken-Onion-Tomato-Ranch. Very clean place, friendly staff,... read more

    Adem Birson Avatar Adem Birson
    June 29, 2022

    We ordered baked ravioli, linguine Alfredo and a couple deserts. They told me it would arrive in 30 minutes, which it did. The guy in the phone was... read more

    David Donner Avatar David Donner
    May 6, 2023

    I love & recommend this place!! I enjoy every meal I get from Mama Linos!! Especially since everything is at a very good price!! I go in and eat all... read more

    Alexa Henriquez-Diaz Avatar Alexa Henriquez-Diaz
    November 25, 2019

    Dope customer experience from the gentleman working in the front. He had a bit of an accent but the gentleman was really courteous. Did I mention the pizza and broccoli pinwheel... read more

    Mohammad Mashriqi Avatar Mohammad Mashriqi
    July 4, 2023

    Mamalino’s never disappoints! The pepperoni pinwheel is one of my favorites, especially for how good it is for the price. The buffalo chicken pizza and buffalo chicken roll are both... read more

    shaun simon Avatar shaun simon
    October 24, 2026

    Excellent spot and the owner is cool! they are open late and I really appreciate that.

    Isrelly1 Bajayo Avatar Isrelly1 Bajayo
    September 21, 2024
  • from the moment I entered the place they welcomed me with a big smile, the lasagna was very delicious and I am thinking of visiting them again, I wish them... read more

    Maye Fra Avatar Maye Fra
    August 27, 2019

    Absolutely I’m love with this place ! My sons baseball team and parents were all in the dining room we got to use it for free!!! They were so nice,... read more

    Ashley Koalski Avatar Ashley Koalski
    November 28, 2019

    Amazing food, chicken and rice tastes fantastic. Service is great and incredibly kind. So happy they are open later now! I plan to come at 1:39 am for my daily... read more

    MiniJRok Avatar MiniJRok
    February 7, 2024

    Really great local pizza and italian food joint. Carry out, delivery and limited eat in. Good food. Prepared quickly. Reasonable specials. Go to place when I'm... read more

    Eric Goldblatt Avatar Eric Goldblatt
    February 19, 2021

    Excellent

    Ace Smith Avatar Ace Smith
    February 9, 2023

    Delivery problems for a birthday party, but my daughter loved it! It's the best pizza for parties. My daughter isn't even a fan of pizza, but she enjoyed it.

    Anita Lee Avatar Anita Lee
    March 17, 2024
  • Reasonable prices & large portions. I was thrilled to see my salad was chopped the way I like it. Staff is friendly. I used to go to another place nearby... read more

    Jill Romanowski Avatar Jill Romanowski
    April 9, 2023

    WOW! My husband and I wanted pizza at 10pm and everything in the area was closed. This popped up on Google and we figured we'd try it out and we... read more

    Dana Bryant Avatar Dana Bryant
    July 18, 2025

    Best pizza in town definitely recommend this place for everyone who loves real authentic Italian food. The pizza with some many toppings and the pasta is so hot and fresh... read more

    Alfredo Alvarez Avatar Alfredo Alvarez
    October 26, 2019

    Ended up here after a concert at Jones Beach. And couldn't believe it wasn't busier bc it's only 20 ish mins away! And it was fantastic! Just a classic nice... read more

    Leelee Avatar Leelee
    October 6, 2025

    It is a wonderful place, the staff is very friendly and I really recommend it to go and enjoy delicious dishes

    Katerin Sanchez Avatar Katerin Sanchez
    August 27, 2019

    Staff was very friendly and pizza was absolutely fantastic 👌 would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a great pizza 🍕

    John Amaral Avatar John Amaral
    July 14, 2021