This is the best pizza! The crust is thin and perfectly cooked and the cheese and sauce are amazing. My favorite pizza is the Chicken-Onion-Tomato-Ranch. Very clean place, friendly staff,... read more and right next to John’s Market. Love it!!!

This place has been my go-to pizza spot for years. I got a cheese pie and meatball pasta to go for the family, and we were all utterly disappointed. Pizza... read more was way too salty and the crust, which is my fav part was not crispy. The pasta noodles were overcooked and tasted worse than a store bought pasta. Not sure what changed, but sad to say I will not be returning here.

Dope customer experience from the gentleman working in the front. He had a bit of an accent but the gentleman was really courteous. Did I mention the pizza and broccoli pinwheel... read more was amazing. This is my new pizza fix.

The Pizza here straight from Italy. Crust is crispy and very light. High quality ingredients and the staff are super friendly. Highly recommend. Try the grandma slice.

This place is amazing i come here multiple days out of the week and it never disappoints. The people here are so kind and serve the best food.

Staff was very friendly and pizza was absolutely fantastic 👌 would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a great pizza 🍕

Best pizza in town definitely recommend this place for everyone who loves real authentic Italian food. The pizza with some many toppings and the pasta is so hot and fresh... read more been coming to this place for years this place is always ready to serve you a hot slice come on down you won’t regret it.

Excellent

Mama Lino’s has got to be the best pizza in town! After a rough day, i’m always sure to hit this place up because it never fails to satisfy my... read more hunger! They’re cheesy pizza and AMAZING crust just hits the spot every time. As well, the beautiful blonde cashier is always such a sweetheart! She is so kind and helpful and just knows what she’s doing. Great place.

Pizza is okay. Place is very clean and staff are extremely friendly. Parking is a major problem during busy hours due to John's farm next door.

You cannot get better value for pizza. It is rather crazy how these guys are able to operate by selling a pizza pie under 18 dollars. Grandma slice is good... read more as well, as white. Make sure you eat the pizza when it is hot or ask them to warm it up, definitely makes a difference in taste.

fantastic food and open late, perfect!

Ordered a few things for delivery after receiving the flyer in the mail. It states that it would take 40 minutes for delivery, but ended up taking an hour and... read more a half -though it’s only a mile away. After 2 calls to slice, the delivery medium, it was delivered cold. We paid extra for sausage on a personal pizza (was like a deep dish) but didn’t get it. Had to heat it up in the oven. Food was okay after being reheated.

Get here regularly. They are awesome. Amazing pizza. Love you guys

Love this place and the people working there, there friendly and have really good customer service 10/10

Excellent food. Porcuito roll thing was out of this world.

I'm from NY originally,I've been bouncing around the country with my job for the last 20 years. First time I've been back in at least 15,I asked the gentleman at... read more the front desk of the hotel I'm at, where's the best pizza? He instantly answered,Mama Lino's. Well,I ordered a pizza tonight,was told 35-45 minutes,lol 24 minutes flat. Piping hot, exactly as I ordered, delivery guy was super friendly and obviously friends with the local police. Absolutely incredible pie,this is the way pizza is supposed to,and always should be. I don't care what part of the country you are in,this is the one. Period Kudos and Thanks a Million Mama Lino's!!!

Try the new dining room. You are in for a fabulous dining experience. Great food personal service at very very reasonable prices.

Have never experienced such a great quality pizzeria that tastes consistently amazing. The specialty slices are great, everything about all their pies are great. Great tasting marinara, great crust, and... read more great prices!!

The staff here is unbelievably friendly and make great New York style pizza. Very consistent quality. It’s a great place to pick up a bite while you wait for your... read more haircut or after picking up groceries. Do your self a favor and try the zeppoles or the pinwheels.

I had the grilled chicken panini and the Buffalo chicken slice of pizza. The staff was very patient and the food was amazing. I will definitely be coming back here... read more to give my service

WOW! My husband and I wanted pizza at 10pm and everything in the area was closed. This popped up on Google and we figured we'd try it out and we... read more LOVED it! The regular and Sicilian slices were fantastic and he loved his chicken parm slices as well. The penne ala vodka was also delicious, and we were full and happy after eating. We work late nights so we were ecstatic to see how late this place is opened. The food was better than we expected and we will DEFINITELY be back!

Food is very satisfactory. I love their Shrimp Francese! And their very typical NY pizza 🤎.

Reasonable prices & large portions. I was thrilled to see my salad was chopped the way I like it. Staff is friendly. I used to go to another place nearby... read more (whose name I won’t mention) & they were overpriced, had small portions of food & it was always served with a side of attitude. Not this place. Mama Lino’s is my new go to place for Italian.

Bought a large Pizza Pie, and it was awesome.

Owner Joe is a real gentleman and truly cares about customer service! I tried the Chicken Primavera for the first time and it was really delicious!

Love the pizza and that it’s open late till 2am wed -sat!!

I ate the best pie after a long time.. the dough is so fresh and the toppings are really good un this. The staff is very friendly. Definitely Will be... read more back

Best pizza in Plainview

The regular pizza is not a good recipe at all - almost inedible. Place is dated and smells funny. 1st and last time. Sorry.

We ordered Chicken Parmigiana Pizza and Garlic Bread with Cheese for delivery. They delivered ahead of the expected time which was great. The pizza and the garlic bread was just... read more alright. Don’t think we’ll be ordering again.

I I recently moved to Hicksville.I ordered two pies and and pasta.The delivery was very fast also the food tasted delicious and very affordable for the pizzerias around the area!

Really great local pizza and italian food joint. Carry out, delivery and limited eat in. Good food. Prepared quickly. Reasonable specials. Go to place when I'm... read more in town

pizza was really good especially the buffalo slice. great service too

I love the Italian music and the food is always warm and delicious! I’m extremely happy that they are open until 2:00 AM now and that the quality of the... read more restaurant is the same from opening until their new, later closing. The employees and boss are wonderful!

Honestly the best pizza ever. I just ordered a pie half chicken parmigiana and half eggplant, my kids scarfed it down in minutes! The owners are the nicest... read more people you will ever meet. You can choose from their ready deep dish slices or order special pies, everything is delicious!

This place is fantastic I came here with my whole family and everyone loved it the pizza was soo good there specialty slices we delicious one of the best pizza... read more ever the food was fantastic we order a fettuccine Alfredo with chicken,penne fiorentina , chicken contadina a baked ziti and more I really recommend it definitely check it out

Mama Lino's always comes through for their catered events! Always on time and the food always looks great. Great cheese slice, very very friendly staff and manager, couldnt be happier!

I stopped in here by accident & I have to say it is one of the best cheese slices

It is a very delicious and wonderful restaurant, I recommend it to everyone.

Dope customer experience from the gentleman working in the front. He had a bit of an accent but the gentleman was really courteous. Did I mention the pizza and... read more broccoli pinwheel was amazing. This is my new pizza fix.

Finally found a crispy Deep Dish pizza that's not a doughy Sicilian and delicious Pepperoni, generously spread with slices 😋

Been coming here for years. I have never once had a pie where the bottom or crusts were overdone/burnt. Always perfect and thin 👌🏼

I loved this pizzeria. The quality is amazing, and I really like that the pepperoni pizza doesn’t have too much dough or too much tomato—it’s simply perfect.

from the moment I entered the place they welcomed me with a big smile, the lasagna was very delicious and I am thinking of visiting them again, I wish them... read more to continue prospering

I came to Hicksville in Hope of running into Teresa Caputo but found the best Italian food I've ever eaten. This quaint little pizzeria has lots of charm & the... read more staff there was awesome... Thanks to Kelli, we had amazing service & they even made us a stuffed pizza pie the 2nd time 😊but their lunch specials are unbeatable ( even left-overs later were delish)& fried zucchini was to die for...of course we went back the next day b4 leaving town. We just couldn't help ourselves. Very reasonably priced & large portions. Hope I get to come back again someday.

Ordered on Uber Eats. My grilled chicken was amazing! And so was my sautéed spinach ! The portions are very generous I’m always a happy customer..

Now that they are open until 2 am i was able to order 2 cheese pizzas for me and my friends and it was absolutely delicious! Will definetely be ordering... read more again!

I love & recommend this place!! I enjoy every meal I get from Mama Linos!! Especially since everything is at a very good price!! I go in and eat all... read more the time, mostly their delicious chicken marsala entree!!

The cauliflower pizza was amazing. The best pizza spot and the staff is so friendly. I will not go anywhere else for pizza except to Mama Lino’s for pizza night.

The buffalo chicken slice is the best compared to other local pizza stores located in hicksville! Customer service is really good and staff is very friendly and nice!

I ordered the chicken francese and the chicken contadina and it was so great, probably one of the best dinners I have ever had go check it out

Absolutely I’m love with this place ! My sons baseball team and parents were all in the dining room we got to use it for free!!! They were so nice,... read more we ordered the chicken Parmesan let me tell you the best chicken Parm I have ever had the kids all prefers pizza and now we order them pizza every time after a game. My friend had the seafood supreme it was so delicious and it was such a good price it tasted like I was eating at a high end restaurant.I really recommended make sure you don’t pass out

Fantastic food, quick and friendly service, really just a bunch of great people making great food at affordable prices.