4.4
Based on 334 reviews
  • Best pizza in Plainview

    Bhoges Avatar Bhoges
    August 9, 2023

    This is the best pizza! The crust is thin and perfectly cooked and the cheese and sauce are amazing. My favorite pizza is the Chicken-Onion-Tomato-Ranch. Very clean place, friendly staff,... read more

    Adem Birson Avatar Adem Birson
    June 29, 2022

    Delivery problems for a birthday party, but my daughter loved it! It's the best pizza for parties. My daughter isn't even a fan of pizza, but she enjoyed it.

    Anita Lee Avatar Anita Lee
    March 17, 2024

    We moved to Florida 3 years ago and have not had good New York pizza, up here for a visit staying at the Hilton Garden, I asked... read more

    Lawrence Diaz Avatar Lawrence Diaz
    August 3, 2021

    I'm from NY originally,I've been bouncing around the country with my job for the last 20 years. First time I've been back in at least 15,I asked the gentleman at... read more

    Tim Bethlehem Avatar Tim Bethlehem
    March 11, 2021

    Mama Lino's is the only reason I made it through the pandemic. Everything I have ordered from them far exceeded my expectations in quality, freshness, and value on every beat.... read more

    Shane Pullham Avatar Shane Pullham
    September 9, 2023
  • Went for dinner. They have some tables for sit down meals. Service was great and food was outstanding and reasonably priced.

    CHUCK HERETH Avatar CHUCK HERETH
    March 9, 2023

    Today I had a Montana penne it was great. the veggies were fresh chicken was moist and just the right amount of garlic and oil I def would recommend.

    Jason Molofsky Avatar Jason Molofsky
    January 17, 2020

    Dope customer experience from the gentleman working in the front. He had a bit of an accent but the gentleman was really courteous. Did I mention the pizza and broccoli pinwheel... read more

    Mohammad Mashriqi Avatar Mohammad Mashriqi
    July 4, 2023

    Best grandma pie ever, definitely ordering again

    media thumbnail 0
    miguel carrasco Avatar miguel carrasco
    September 1, 2025

    Ended up here after a concert at Jones Beach. And couldn't believe it wasn't busier bc it's only 20 ish mins away! And it was fantastic! Just a classic nice... read more

    alicia fioco Avatar alicia fioco
    October 6, 2025

    Bought a large Pizza Pie, and it was awesome.

    Charles Sconzo Jr Avatar Charles Sconzo Jr
    June 28, 2025
  • Excellent spot and the owner is cool! they are open late and I really appreciate that.

    Isrelly1 Bajayo Avatar Isrelly1 Bajayo
    September 10, 2024

    from the moment I entered the place they welcomed me with a big smile, the lasagna was very delicious and I am thinking of visiting them again, I wish them... read more

    Maye Fra Avatar Maye Fra
    August 27, 2019

    Everything

    David Menasha Avatar David Menasha
    March 21, 2024

    They make amazing buffalo and BBQ chicken pizzas! Their garlic knots are out of this world fluffy soft and delish! If you are up for pasta, I strongly recommend Chicken... read more

    Judy Zhao Avatar Judy Zhao
    April 6, 2019

    Truly an amazing pizza place with very nice and friendly staff serving some of plainviews best pizza they have to offer. 10/10

    Jude Alexander Avatar Jude Alexander
    November 9, 2023

    The chicken parmesan deep dish pizza is amazing. The toppings are base proportion was perfect and it was loaded. Surprisingly the desserts were also great considering it's a pizza place.... read more

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1
    Ruzan Pithawala Avatar Ruzan Pithawala
    August 24, 2024
  • You cannot get better value for pizza. It is rather crazy how these guys are able to operate by selling a pizza pie under 18 dollars. Grandma slice is good... read more

    Jon Li Avatar Jon Li
    April 12, 2018

    Finally found a crispy Deep Dish pizza that's not a doughy Sicilian and delicious Pepperoni, generously spread with slices 😋

    Lisa Moffa Avatar Lisa Moffa
    September 21, 2025

    Have never experienced such a great quality pizzeria that tastes consistently amazing. The specialty slices are great, everything about all their pies are great. Great tasting marinara, great crust, and... read more

    Elias Assimakopoulos Avatar Elias Assimakopoulos
    December 21, 2024

    Their dough is amazing, and everything they make with it is the perfect mix of chewy and crispy. The slices, the garlic knots, the calzones, all tasty and made with... read more

    Sam Pullman Avatar Sam Pullman
    May 25, 2023

    Owner Joe is a real gentleman and truly cares about customer service! I tried the Chicken Primavera for the first time and it was really delicious!

    Ben P. Avatar Ben P.
    July 9, 2023

    Best pizza I've ever had. The garlic knots are delicious, the sauce is perfect. I order a simple pepperoni pizza garlic knots. The owner was very kind. The girl who... read more

    Alpha Lister Avatar Alpha Lister
    July 26, 2021
  • As someone who takes food seriously, I’ve had pizza from a ton of different spots — but honestly, most places just can’t get the dough right. Ever since I discovered Mama... read more

    serkan şahin Avatar serkan şahin
    October 19, 2025

    Strongly recommend 👍👍 pizzas, sides and desserts.. everything so yummy

    ibrahim elbir Avatar ibrahim elbir
    February 3, 2023

    The staff is friendly and feels like I am part of their family every time I walk in at Mama Lino’s. I love all of the food that they serve.... read more

    Ana Alvarez Avatar Ana Alvarez
    April 7, 2019

    We ordered baked ravioli, linguine Alfredo and a couple deserts. They told me it would arrive in 30 minutes, which it did. The guy in the phone was... read more

    David Donner Avatar David Donner
    May 6, 2023

    My family and I LOVE this place!! We buy pizza every Friday night and REALLY ENJOY the leftovers, if there are any 😊 The warm, friendly welcome I receive... read more

    Janine Evans Avatar Janine Evans
    November 23, 2019

    good food good prices

    Mathew Hall Avatar Mathew Hall
    February 19, 2025
  • Mama Lino’s has got to be the best pizza in town! After a rough day, i’m always sure to hit this place up because it never fails to satisfy my... read more

    Helen Parv Avatar Helen Parv
    April 16, 2024

    Kind service and tasty pizza!!

    Deborah E. Chung Avatar Deborah E. Chung
    April 9, 2023

    Amazing food. Got the chance to eat the tortellini in brodo soup it is a must try. They also have great pizza. I highly recommend the personal margharita pizza. Staff... read more

    gina brindisi Avatar gina brindisi
    September 28, 2023

    Amazing Place to dine!!! The pizza knocks every other place in the area out of the park!

    jamie spotify Avatar jamie spotify
    November 9, 2023

    WOW! My husband and I wanted pizza at 10pm and everything in the area was closed. This popped up on Google and we figured we'd try it out and we... read more

    Dana Bryant Avatar Dana Bryant
    July 18, 2025

    Staff was very friendly and pizza was absolutely fantastic 👌 would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a great pizza 🍕

    John Amaral Avatar John Amaral
    July 14, 2021
  • The pizza was delicious and I really recommend to go and enjoy with friends or family and try some of the delicious dishes that they prepare

    Edenilson Francia Avatar Edenilson Francia
    August 27, 2019

    Ordered on Uber Eats. My grilled chicken was amazing! And so was my sautéed spinach ! The portions are very generous I’m always a happy customer..

    Nadia74 Avatar Nadia74
    April 24, 2026

    The Pizza here straight from Italy. Crust is crispy and very light. High quality ingredients and the staff are super friendly. Highly recommend. Try the grandma slice.

    Sam Khodaparast Avatar Sam Khodaparast
    March 22, 2025

    Pasta and entrees are a must. The penne alla vodka and the chicken parm are exquisite. The real highlight though? The pizza. Enticing allure of aroma when the fresh pies... read more

    MiniJRok Avatar MiniJRok
    August 4, 2026

    The absolute best pizza in town and catered a lot of food from them for a party and it was perfect! So much food, delicious and the manager threw in... read more

    Jonathan Pollino Avatar Jonathan Pollino
    September 20, 2022

    Now that they are open until 2 am i was able to order 2 cheese pizzas for me and my friends and it was absolutely delicious! Will definetely be ordering... read more

    Joe Zizzo Avatar Joe Zizzo
    February 6, 2024
  • The pizza should be named best in Long Island. Love it. Great prices.

    Lisa2 party Morse Avatar Lisa2 party Morse
    July 9, 2022

    Love this place, been coming here for years and there food never disappoints👍🏼

    Jay Marr Avatar Jay Marr
    May 22, 2021

    It is a wonderful place, the staff is very friendly and I really recommend it to go and enjoy delicious dishes

    Katerin Sanchez Avatar Katerin Sanchez
    August 27, 2019

    Nowhere near the best pizza in town like some other reviews suggest. The pizza is ok. I've had their pizza a handful of times because my daughter likes their pizza.... read more

    Jordan G Avatar Jordan G
    January 13, 2023

    fantastic food and open late, perfect!

    Brian Choi Avatar Brian Choi
    February 7, 2024

    The food was very good and they’re open late.

    Jenni Cruz Avatar Jenni Cruz
    June 16, 2025
  • I frequent this spot when I'm craving pizza, shoutout to Bill for exceptional quality and professionalism!! I've ordered with him multiple times and hands down incredible consistency and quality. Some... read more

    Jesse Hirshon Avatar Jesse Hirshon
    August 12, 2026

    My wife and i love this place. Great meatballs.

    Anthony Vinciguerra Avatar Anthony Vinciguerra
    February 9, 2023

    I went here for a quick lunch and I ordered the penne alla vodka with grilled chicken and it was absolutely delicious! , I’ll surely be coming back for more... read more

    Jennifer Lynch Avatar Jennifer Lynch
    November 27, 2017

    This place has been my go-to pizza spot for years. I got a cheese pie and meatball pasta to go for the family, and we were all utterly disappointed. Pizza... read more

    media thumbnail 0
    Anna Yeo Avatar Anna Yeo
    January 26, 2024

    It is a wonderful place, the staff is very friendly and I really recommend it to go and enjoy delicious dishes

    Katerin Sanchez Avatar Katerin Sanchez
    August 27, 2019

    A little hidden gem. Pizza was good but the Sicilian was AMAGING!! The dough wasn't too heavy and the sauce was delicious.

    Alicia Millette Avatar Alicia Millette
    May 16, 2021
  • Honestly the best pizza ever. I just ordered a pie half chicken parmigiana and half eggplant, my kids scarfed it down in minutes! The owners are the nicest... read more

    Mimi Saab Avatar Mimi Saab
    July 8, 2021

    Love the pizza and that it’s open late till 2am wed -sat!!

    Davi Vanegas Avatar Davi Vanegas
    September 21, 2024

    This place is fantastic I came here with my whole family and everyone loved it the pizza was soo good there specialty slices we delicious one of the best pizza... read more

    Ana Smith Avatar Ana Smith
    January 6, 2019

    Excellent spot and the owner is cool! they are open late and I really appreciate that.

    Isrelly1 Bajayo Avatar Isrelly1 Bajayo
    September 21, 2024

    I ate the best pie after a long time.. the dough is so fresh and the toppings are really good un this. The staff is very friendly. Definitely Will be... read more

    Jose maldonado Avatar Jose maldonado
    July 8, 2018

    Went in today and got chicken parm entree and overall very good , came with garlic knots and they were nice and fresh.

    Joanna Henriquez Avatar Joanna Henriquez
    January 6, 2019