4.4
Based on 324 reviews
  • Excellent

    Ace Smith Avatar Ace Smith
    February 9, 2023

    WOW! My husband and I wanted pizza at 10pm and everything in the area was closed. This popped up on Google and we figured we'd try it out and we... read more

    Dana Bryant Avatar Dana Bryant
    July 18, 2025

    The pizza was delicious and I really recommend to go and enjoy with friends or family and try some of the delicious dishes that they prepare

    Edenilson Francia Avatar Edenilson Francia
    August 27, 2019

    from the moment I entered the place they welcomed me with a big smile, the lasagna was very delicious and I am thinking of visiting them again, I wish them... read more

    Maye Fra Avatar Maye Fra
    August 27, 2019

    Try the new dining room. You are in for a fabulous dining experience. Great food personal service at very very reasonable prices.

    Bernard Perini Avatar Bernard Perini
    December 15, 2017

    I was shopping at John's Farm's and was hungry so I decided to stop by and check the menu and landed on chicken Alfredo pasta. It was so good it... read more

    Fredo Alv Avatar Fredo Alv
    April 6, 2018
  • Honestly the best pizza ever. I just ordered a pie half chicken parmigiana and half eggplant, my kids scarfed it down in minutes! The owners are the nicest... read more

    Mimi Saab Avatar Mimi Saab
    July 8, 2021

    As an LI native, this is as pure as LI pizza gets. Delivery was quick, pizza was inhaled hot, and the garlic knots were so fresh and delicious I annihilated... read more

    Matt Avatar Matt
    November 25, 2021

    I called in a order for delivery and I was very pleased with the order. The person that took my order said it would take about 40 minutes my order... read more

    Danniel Dominguez Avatar Danniel Dominguez
    December 5, 2020

    The pizza was delicious and I really recommend to go and enjoy with friends or family and try some of the delicious dishes that they prepare

    Edenilson Francia Avatar Edenilson Francia
    August 27, 2019

    Finally found a crispy Deep Dish pizza that's not a doughy Sicilian and delicious Pepperoni, generously spread with slices 😋

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1
    Lisa Moffa Avatar Lisa Moffa
    September 21, 2025

    We ordered Chicken Parmigiana Pizza and Garlic Bread with Cheese for delivery. They delivered ahead of the expected time which was great. The pizza and the garlic bread was just... read more

    Christine C Avatar Christine C
    November 25, 2019
  • Been coming here for years. I have never once had a pie where the bottom or crusts were overdone/burnt. Always perfect and thin 👌🏼

    Timothy L Avatar Timothy L
    December 24, 2021

    I have been ordering food almost every other night my family just loves it and it’s so cheap and delivery is so fast! My son recommended Mama Linos to their... read more

    Susan Gerise Avatar Susan Gerise
    November 25, 2019

    I came to Hicksville in Hope of running into Teresa Caputo but found the best Italian food I've ever eaten. This quaint little pizzeria has lots of charm & the... read more

    T Wheeler Avatar T Wheeler
    August 22, 2018

    This place is amazing i come here multiple days out of the week and it never disappoints. The people here are so kind and serve the best food.

    Hans Avatar Hans
    August 5, 2026

    The pizza should be named best in Long Island. Love it. Great prices.

    Lisa2 party Morse Avatar Lisa2 party Morse
    July 9, 2022

    You cannot get better value for pizza. It is rather crazy how these guys are able to operate by selling a pizza pie under 18 dollars. Grandma slice is good... read more

    Jon Li Avatar Jon Li
    April 12, 2018
  • As someone who takes food seriously, I’ve had pizza from a ton of different spots — but honestly, most places just can’t get the dough right. Ever since I discovered Mama... read more

    serkan şahin Avatar serkan şahin
    October 19, 2025

    Have never experienced such a great quality pizzeria that tastes consistently amazing. The specialty slices are great, everything about all their pies are great. Great tasting marinara, great crust, and... read more

    Elias Assimakopoulos Avatar Elias Assimakopoulos
    December 21, 2024

    Reasonable prices & large portions. I was thrilled to see my salad was chopped the way I like it. Staff is friendly. I used to go to another place nearby (whose... read more

    Jill Romanowski Avatar Jill Romanowski
    April 9, 2023

    The owners of this place definitely care about what they serve. Whatever i have tried; soup, salad, pizza or main course, everything is meticulously prepared.

    Oytun Akar Avatar Oytun Akar
    October 18, 2018

    Best pizza in Plainview

    Bhoges Avatar Bhoges
    August 9, 2023

    Amazing pizza

    Leah Hare Avatar Leah Hare
    October 10, 2025
  • Staff was very friendly and pizza was absolutely fantastic 👌 would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a great pizza 🍕

    John Amaral Avatar John Amaral
    July 14, 2021

    The absolute best pizza in town and catered a lot of food from them for a party and it was perfect! So much food, delicious and the manager threw in... read more

    Jonathan Pollino Avatar Jonathan Pollino
    September 20, 2022

    Ended up here after a concert at Jones Beach. And couldn't believe it wasn't busier bc it's only 20 ish mins away! And it was fantastic! Just a classic nice... read more

    Leelee Avatar Leelee
    October 6, 2025

    I ate at MamaLinos restaurant and I had a variety of foods for me and my family which included their wonderful pizza and baked ziti. The owner is very helpful... read more

    Courtney Roberts Avatar Courtney Roberts
    September 23, 2020

    Dope customer experience from the gentleman working in the front. He had a bit of an accent but the gentleman was really courteous. Did I mention the pizza and... read more

    Mohammad Mashriqi Avatar Mohammad Mashriqi
    July 9, 2023

    I order from mama Lino’s all the time! Pizza is always perfect. The service is always great, staff is super friendly.. super reasonably priced and my food never takes too... read more

    Juli LaGois Avatar Juli LaGois
    April 16, 2024
  • Got the buffalo chicken roll and garlic knots, was delicious, definitely recommend, would get again. Garlic knots tasted fresh and had lots of fresh garlic and olive oil, the buffalo... read more

    Vishal Boodhan Avatar Vishal Boodhan
    August 17, 2020

    Food is very satisfactory. I love their Shrimp Francese! And their very typical NY pizza 🤎.

    Daisy Avatar Daisy
    March 13, 2025

    The Pizza here straight from Italy. Crust is crispy and very light. High quality ingredients and the staff are super friendly. Highly recommend. Try the grandma slice.

    Sam Khodaparast Avatar Sam Khodaparast
    March 22, 2025

    Mama Lino’s has got to be the best pizza in town! After a rough day, i’m always sure to hit this place up because it never fails to satisfy my... read more

    Helen Parv Avatar Helen Parv
    April 16, 2024

    Went in for the first time last week, and it was awesome. The service from the counter girls was very helpful. The pizza came out delicious and my girlfriend also... read more

    Nick Russo Avatar Nick Russo
    February 27, 2025

    Best pizza on Long Island, deep dish pies are the best. Price is always good no matter what you get and the portion sizes are huge !!

    joe hansen Avatar joe hansen
    May 31, 2019
  • I I recently moved to Hicksville.I ordered two pies and and pasta.The delivery was very fast also the food tasted delicious and very affordable for the pizzerias around the area!

    Chris Jensen Avatar Chris Jensen
    May 24, 2020

    This place has been my go-to pizza spot for years. I got a cheese pie and meatball pasta to go for the family, and we were all utterly disappointed. Pizza... read more

    media thumbnail 0
    Anna Yeo Avatar Anna Yeo
    January 26, 2024

    The cauliflower pizza was amazing. The best pizza spot and the staff is so friendly. I will not go anywhere else for pizza except to Mama Lino’s for pizza night.

    Ana Angelica Alvarez Avatar Ana Angelica Alvarez
    April 7, 2019

    Now that they are open until 2 am i was able to order 2 cheese pizzas for me and my friends and it was absolutely delicious! Will definetely be ordering... read more

    Joe Zizzo Avatar Joe Zizzo
    February 6, 2024

    Get here regularly. They are awesome. Amazing pizza. Love you guys

    Michelle Grohosky Avatar Michelle Grohosky
    March 6, 2022

    Their dough is amazing, and everything they make with it is the perfect mix of chewy and crispy. The slices, the garlic knots, the calzones, all tasty and made with... read more

    Sam Pullman Avatar Sam Pullman
    May 25, 2023
  • Pretty good slice I must say. Will definitely be back when in the area.

    Brian BAtes Avatar Brian BAtes
    January 12, 2024

    I had a delicious veal entree the other night and it was amazing now i have to try the new Cauliflower crust pizza!! incredible 🙂

    Joanna Henriquez Avatar Joanna Henriquez
    March 28, 2019

    pizza was really good especially the buffalo slice. great service too

    Brandon Avatar Brandon
    September 9, 2023

    Kind service and tasty pizza!!

    Deborah E. Chung Avatar Deborah E. Chung
    April 9, 2023

    This place is fantastic I came here with my whole family and everyone loved it the pizza was soo good there specialty slices we delicious one of the best pizza... read more

    Ana Smith Avatar Ana Smith
    January 6, 2019

    Food was Delicious and serve was at top notch. 5 stars.

    nhytr khan Avatar nhytr khan
    July 20, 2019
  • We moved to Florida 3 years ago and have not had good New York pizza, up here for a visit staying at the Hilton Garden, I asked... read more

    Lawrence Diaz Avatar Lawrence Diaz
    August 3, 2021

    It is a wonderful place, the staff is very friendly and I really recommend it to go and enjoy delicious dishes

    Katerin Sanchez Avatar Katerin Sanchez
    August 27, 2019

    The chicken parmesan deep dish pizza is amazing. The toppings are base proportion was perfect and it was loaded. Surprisingly the desserts were also great considering it's a pizza place.... read more

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1
    Ruzan Pithawala Avatar Ruzan Pithawala
    September 21, 2024

    Strongly recommend 👍👍 pizzas, sides and desserts.. everything so yummy

    ibrahim elbir Avatar ibrahim elbir
    February 3, 2023

    Definitely pizza a bit salty

    Shaniqua Battle Avatar Shaniqua Battle
    February 2, 2024

    We enjoy the food often. Always delicious. Friendly and efficient staff.

    Robin Hartman Avatar Robin Hartman
    July 10, 2019
  • Pasta and entrees are a must. The penne alla vodka and the chicken parm are exquisite. The real highlight though? The pizza. Enticing allure of aroma when the fresh pies... read more

    MiniJRok Avatar MiniJRok
    August 4, 2026

    Great pizza , nice people 👌

    Adam Arguijo Avatar Adam Arguijo
    June 21, 2024

    The food was very good and they’re open late.

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1media thumbnail 2media thumbnail 3media thumbnail 4
    Jenni Cruz Avatar Jenni Cruz
    June 16, 2025

    Ended up here after a concert at Jones Beach. And couldn't believe it wasn't busier bc it's only 20 ish mins away! And it was fantastic! Just a classic nice... read more

    alicia fioco Avatar alicia fioco
    October 6, 2025

    Pizza slices are bigger and fluffy but feels very light after eating. One of the best pizza dough I have eaten in past 20 years. Delicious Gradmas pizza 🍕

    Sameer Vora Avatar Sameer Vora
    January 31, 2025

    Mama Lino's always comes through for their catered events! Always on time and the food always looks great. Great cheese slice, very very friendly staff and manager, couldnt be happier!

    Sally Finn Avatar Sally Finn
    February 2, 2019